Signal Autopsy

3 of 9 popular indicators still worked on later prices after all 54 tests were counted.

This page tests popular market rules on later prices, counts every attempted time window and shows when a striking result depends on one rule.

3 SURVIVE
Indicators checked9Popular market rules
Time windows checked54Every rule across every time window
Still worked later3 of 9Worked on prices not used to choose the rule
Did not hold up6Useful for description, not forecasting
Best surviving ruleWhat Bitcoin did last monthAbout 20 days ahead
Later hit rate51%Versus 33% staying invested
Later occasions47From Oct 2024
Extra later return+12.5%Against the broad market result
Current reading5.4Higher than 57% of its history
Strongest link to later price0.162Near zero means little connection
Shortest useful window5 daysAmong surviving rules
Survivors without best2Best rule removed

Ask this page.

Choose a useful question or type your own. The answer and chart use only the figures already checked for this page.

Choose a question to build a chart.

Current viewWaiting for a question

The chart will appear here.

Which rules held up?

Every rule had to work on later prices it was not chosen on. All attempted time windows were counted.

IndicatorVerdictBest windowLink to later priceRight laterStay investedExtra returnLater occasions
What Bitcoin did last monthHeld up20 days0.16251%33%+12.5%47
How many coins are above trendHeld up5 days0.07448%43%+0.3%66
How differently coins are movingHeld up10 days0.02845%43%+2.1%101
How many coins are overextendedDid not hold up20 days0.15033%33%-0.9%89
How many coins are at a three-month lowDid not hold up30 days0.10034%30%+1.6%229
How violent the last month has beenDid not hold up20 days0.07714%33%+0.2%29
How much the market moves as oneDid not hold up90 days0.06035%25%+1.8%187
How far Bitcoin is below its highDid not hold up90 days0.05657%24%+26.5%68
How many coins are beating BitcoinDid not hold up5 days0.03338%44%-1.7%81

3 of 9 popular indicators still worked on later prices after all 54 tests were counted. The rest may still describe the market, but this record does not support a forecasting claim.

Does one rule carry the story?

Remove the strongest survivor and count again.

All surviving rules3
Without the best2

Without What Bitcoin did last month, 2 indicators still pass.

Research by for Charlie Quant Lab · Updated